Short answer: In 2027, the CISO you hire must secure AI as well as networks, speak the board's language and manage growing regulation, in a market where good candidates have options. Median US CISO total compensation reached $880,000 including equity in Heidrick & Struggles' 2025 survey (Heidrick & Struggles), and 68% of large-enterprise CISOs are considering a move or are undecided (IANS). Define the mandate, reporting line and pay before you start the search.
[Table 1]
Gartner predicts that by 2028, 50% of enterprise incident response will focus on custom-built AI applications, and more than half of enterprises will use AI security platforms (Gartner). Search firms already see it in briefs: Christian & Timbers reports that all 32 CISO and CSO replacement searches it tracked from January to July 2026 named deep agentic AI expertise as the most critical qualification, up from 9 of 22 a year earlier (Christian & Timbers).
Gartner expects that through 2027, manual AI compliance processes will expose 75% of regulated organizations to fines of more than 5% of global revenue (Gartner). Your next CISO needs a plan for AI governance and automated compliance, not just a policy.
By 2028, 70% of CISOs will use identity visibility and intelligence tools to shrink the identity attack surface, according to Gartner. As AI agents act on behalf of users, managing non-human identities becomes a core CISO skill.
Heidrick & Struggles' survey of 371 CISOs puts the US median at $510,000 in cash and $880,000 including equity, with the 95th percentile of total cash rising to $1.6 million. IANS and Artico Search report a $508,000 median total package at companies above $1 billion and $293,000 in cash below $1 billion (IANS). See CISO salary 2026.
In Heidrick & Struggles' survey, 42% of CISOs reported to the CEO, about 3 times the prior year's share, and 30% to a technology executive. The IANS and Artico Search benchmark, with a larger North American sample, still finds 64% reporting into IT (IANS and Artico Search). The trend is clear even if the numbers differ: more companies want security independent from IT. See CISO titles and reporting lines.
IANS found only 30% of boards describe their CISO relationship as strong and collaborative. CISOs get about 30 minutes with the board, and directors rate reporting on evolving threats and AI risk as the weakest areas, needing improvement for 53% and 47% of directors (IANS). Hire for board communication, not just technical depth.
The SEC dismissed its landmark case against SolarWinds and its CISO with prejudice in November 2025. Lawyers caution that companies should not read this as relaxed expectations (McGuireWoods). Expect candidates to ask about D&O insurance, indemnification and their role in disclosure decisions.
Choose who the CISO reports to and how often they meet the board or a committee. Strong candidates ask this first. If the CISO reports to the CIO, give a direct line to the audit or risk committee.
Benchmark base, bonus and equity against companies of your size and sector. Include sign-on equity if you are asking a candidate to leave unvested awards. Confirm D&O coverage and indemnification in the offer.
Agree the first board presentation date, the risk assessment timeline and the budget review before the start date. A clear onboarding plan reduces early turnover, which matters when many sitting CISOs are already open to offers.
Related: skills, not headcount: ISC2 data and Palantir CISO nominated to lead CISA.
Companies will look for CISOs who can secure AI systems and agents, report confidently to the board and handle growing regulation. Pay and competition stay high: median US CISO total compensation was $880,000 in Heidrick & Struggles' 2025 survey, and many sitting CISOs are open to a move.
Benchmarks vary by company size. IANS and Artico Search put median total pay at $508,000 for companies above $1 billion in revenue and median cash pay at $293,000 below $1 billion. Heidrick & Struggles reports a US median of $880,000 including equity. Budget for total compensation, not base.
There is no single answer. In Heidrick & Struggles' 2025 survey, 42% of CISOs reported to the CEO. In the IANS and Artico Search benchmark, 64% still reported into IT. What matters most is direct, regular access to the board or a board committee.
Securing AI applications and agents, identity security, board communication, regulatory knowledge and the ability to build team skills. ISC2 found AI is the top skill gap in security teams at 41%.
A retained executive search for a CISO commonly takes 3 to 6 months from kickoff to start date, depending on scope, location and notice periods. Defining the mandate before the search starts shortens it.
The risk is lower but not gone. The SEC dismissed its case against SolarWinds and its CISO with prejudice in November 2025, but lawyers advise companies not to read this as relaxed expectations. Offer D&O insurance coverage and clear indemnification.